Must we tolerate the intolerant?
In his 1945 book ‘The Open Society and its Enemies’ the philosopher Karl Popper puts forward the idea that unlimited tolerance destroys tolerance itself.
Popper thought it was unwise to suppress intolerant views if they could be challenged rationally. But he also argues that society should retain the right to intervene, by force if necessary and in extremis, if people persist in using threatening, abusive or intimidatory language or behaviour to express a view or an argument. Similarly, if they repeat a lie often enough attempting to get others to believe an untruth.

As a teacher, I always wanted to encourage in the children I taught the idea that listening to other people express unpopular or unfashionable views was a virtuous act of tolerance. If you do that, you are trying to be a good teacher, encourage the virtue of tolerance and in my view, promote a fundamental British value.
But if such expressions can’t be challenged rationally, teachers must step in to regulate the expression of intolerant language and lies in order to preserve tolerance itself. That’s your duty too – as a teacher and as a citizen in a civilised society.

Alan Newland leads sessions with trainee-teachers on how to promote fundamental British values in schools. Contact him if you would like him to lead such a session at your SCITT or university.
He is also the author of the highly acclaimed ‘Becoming a Teacher – the legal, ethical and moral implications of entering society’s most fundamental profession’ (Crown House Publishing)






Comments